Research Article

Composition of Flatbreads Prepared from Blue, Red, Yellow, and White Corn Flours Supplemented with Edible Ecklonia cava Algae: Relationship to Health Benefits

by Talwinder Kahlon*, Mendel Friedman

Healthy Processed Foods Research, Western Regional Research Center, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Albany, CA 94710, USA

*Corresponding author: Talwinder Kahlon, Healthy Processed Foods Research, Western Regional Research Center, Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture, Albany, CA 94710, USA

Received Date: 04 March 2024

Accepted Date: 11 March 2024

Published Date: 15 March 2024

Citation: Kahlon T, Friedman M (2024) Composition of Flatbreads Prepared from Blue, Red, Yellow, and White Corn Flours Supplemented with Edible Ecklonia cava Algae: Relationship to Health Benefits. Food Nutr J 9: 293. https://doi.org/10.29011/2575-7091.100193

Abstract

The objective of the present study was to determine the composition of flatbreads prepared from corn and wheat flours supplemented with edible Ecklonia cava, which is a health-promoting medicinal food used as a dietary supplement. The Corn flours used were Whole Blue, Purcell Whole Blue, Purcell Whole Red, Purcell Whole Yellow, Purcell Whole White and Giant White and King Arthur Whole Wheat. Because the colored corn flours are reported to contain health-promoting anthocyanins and the Ecklonia alga contains multiple biologically active polyphenolic and other health-promoting compounds reported to show anti-asthma, anti-cancer, anti-diabetes, antimicrobial, anti-neurotoxicity, anti-obesity, and cardioprotective effects, the resulting flatbreads have the potential for multiple health benefits in humans after consumption. To facilitate the development of the newly created flatbreads for consumption, we determined, using standard methods, the effect of added E. cava on the proximate composition of protein, fat, carbohydrate, dry matter, ash (mineral), and water content of the flatbreads. The unexpected results, for which we have no explanation, show that the measured protein, mineral, and water content of the E. cava-supplemented flatbreads increased, whereas the fat, carbohydrate, and dry matter contents of the E. cava-supplemented flatbreads decreased compared to un-supplemented ones, suggesting that consumers will be able to select flatbreads with a high-protein and low-fat content.

Keywords: Flatbreads; Blue Corn; Red Corn; Yellow Corn; White Corn; Hard Red Whole Wheat; Ecklonia Cava Algae; Proximate Analysis; Health Benefits; Research Needs

Introduction

As part of efforts to create new functional foods that have the potential to ameliorate and treat human diseases, we reported that edible algae (Ecklonia cava) bioprocessed (fermented) in culture with shiitake mushroom mycelia was effective in neutralizing multiple biomarkers associated with allergic asthma in mice [1]. We also published a series of studies on the preparation of experimental, mostly gluten-free, flatbreads with other health benefits, as well as with a low content of the heat-induced toxin acrylamide formed during the baking process [2-5]. Because edible E. cava algae contain multiple antioxidative polyphenolic compounds that are reported to be safe to consume (discussed below) and to have multiple health benefits in vitro and in vivo (highlighted below), and colored (pigmented) corn flours also contain different health-promoting phenolic compounds and anthocyanins (highlighted below), expectations are that the combination of biologically active compounds present in colored corn flour and the alga might act additively or synergistically against human diseases. These considerations motivated us to prepare another set of flatbreads from colored corn flour and E. cava that might act additively or synergistically in ameliorating the adverse effects of human diseases. The objective of the present study was therefore to prepare and determine the composition of flatbreads from blue, yellow, red, and white corn flours (colored corn flours containing anthocyanins and phenolic compounds) and hard red whole wheat flour supplemented with health-promoting purified commercial E. cava.

Materials and Methods

Ecklonia cava BioPure 300 mg capsules manufactured for BHP Holdings, Inc., Woodinville, WA (info@biopures.com) were purchased online from Amazon. The following corn seeds were purchased online from Purcell Mountain Farms, Moyie Springs, ID, USA (https://purcellmountainfarms.com, accessed on 17 October 2021): Corn, Blue Purcell Corn, Red Corn, White Corn, White Giant Corn, and Yellow Corn. The corn seeds were milled in our laboratory into flour using the Blendtec Kitchen Mill Model 91 at medium setting (Blendtec Inc., Orem, UT 84058, USA). King Arthur hard red whole wheat flour was purchased from the local grocery store.

Preparation of Flatbreads

The composition of flatbreads prepared (170 mL water and 178.65 g ingredients) is given in Table 1. Flatbread dough was prepared by adding 49 ml water to 51 g of ingredients, as shown in Table 2. Water was added slowly in small volumes to flatbread ingredients until the dough began forming a ball. The dough was kneaded until it became smooth and elastic, which determined the exact amount of water needed for each batch of flatbreads. The dough was placed in a Pyrex bowl, covered with a polyvinyl film, and held at room temperature for 30 min. Dough (45 g) was placed on parchment paper (nonstick, oven safe up to 216 °C) and pressed into a thickness of 1–1.5 mm and to a circle of about 17 cm diameter in a 20-cm Alpine Cuisine flatbread Press (Aramco Imports, Inc., Commerce, CA, USA). Flatbreads were cooked between the upper and lower hot irons of the flatbread maker for 2 min (1 min each side) at 165–195 OC on parchment paper in a 1000 Watt CucinaPro Flatbread Maker (SCS Direct, Inc., Trumbull, CT, USA). The cooking temperature was measured by Fluke 61 Infrared Thermometer (www.fluke.com, accessed on 4 April 2022). For crispier or chewier flatbreads, cooking time can be adjusted as desired. The pliable flatbreads could be filled and rolled to make wraps. The resulting flatbreads weighed ~3l g before drying and ~19 g after drying.

Flatbread Proximate Composition analysis

For proximate analysis, cooked flatbreads were chopped for 30 sec in a Cuisinart coffee grinder Model DCG-20N (Cuisinart East Windsor, NJ, USA). Chopped flatbreads were then dried at 130 °Cfor l hr. Complete dryness was confirmed with an additional 30 min of drying. Dried flatbreads were ground to fine powders using a coffee grinder (Cuisinart Model DCG-20N E Windsor NJ, USA). Ground flatbreads were analyzed for Kjeldahl nitrogen using AOAC method 951.03; for crude fat by Soxhlet extraction with petroleum ether using method 963.15; ash, using method 923.03; and moisture, using method 925.10.

Results

Table 1 shows the composition of the dough recipe (flour, guar gum, Ecklonia cava, olive oil, salt, and water) used to bake the flatbreads in terms of grams of each ingredient, Table 2, the corresponding values on a percent basis, and Table 3 nutrient composition on a dry matter basis.  The data show that values for protein content on a gram basis for the six corn and one wheat flour ranged from 5.19 (Purcell Whole Giant White) to 8.65 (Purcell Whole Red), and 15.14 (King Arthur Whole Wheat). Table 3 also shows that, for fat content, the values for the six corns varied by 3.62%, ranging from 10.39 (Purcell Whole White) to 14.01 (Whole Blue), whereas the value for King Arthur Whole wheat of 4.43 was about one-third that of the corns. The carbohydrate (67.43–71.75), dry matter (88.37–91.15), and water (9.85–11.61) values of all samples were within close range. This seems to be the first report on the proximate composition of an E. cava sample, which shows the following values: protein, 2.17; fat, l.27; minerals, 1.09; carbohydrates, 91.17; dry matter, 95.70; and water 4.31. Table 4 shows the composition of the E. cava-supplemented flatbreads on percent dry matter basis. The protein content for the six corns ranged from 6.01 (Purcell Whole Giant White) to 9.78 (Purcell Whole Red) and 5.35 for King Arthur Whole Wheat.

The corresponding values for the fat content are 4.69 (Whole

Blue) to 6.67 (Purcell Whole Red) and 3.81 (King Arthur Whole Wheat). The values for carbohydrate dry matter, and water are in close range. The following results demonstrate the large changes in the composition of the analyzed flatbreads that resulted from adding the E. cava to the dough recipe. The last column in Table 5 shows that the protein content on a dry matter basis of the eight flatbreads increased, ranging from a 46.59% increase (King Arthur Wheat) to a 76.41% increase (Giant White Corn). Table 6 shows that the protein content on a wet weight basis increased from 20.41% (Purcell Whole Giant White) to 45.34% (Purcell Whole

Red). Table 7 shows that the fat content decreased, ranging from

-32.99% (King Arthur Whole Wheat) to -60.35% (Whole Blue Corn). Table 8 shows that increases in mineral content ranged from 2.57% (King Arthur Whole Wheat) to 14.02% (Purcell Whole Blue Corn). Table 9 shows that the carbohydrate content decreased, ranging from -5.84% (Whole Blue Com) to -17.72% (King Arthur Whole Wheat). Table 10 shows that dry matter also decreases from -4.74% (Purcell Whole Red Corn) to -18.13% (Purcell Whole Giant White Corn). Finally, Table 11 shows that the increase in water content ranged from 13.48% (Purcell Whole Red Corn) to 23.84% (Purcell Whole Giant White Corn). We have no explanation for the described positive and negative changes in the composition of the flatbreads apparently caused by added E. cava.

Flatbread

Flour

Guar Gum

Ecklonia cava

Olive oil

Salt

Water mL

Whole Blue Corn

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

Purell Whole Blue Corn

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

Purell Whole Red Corn

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

Purell Whole Yellow Corn

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

Purell Whole White Corn

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

Purell Whole Gian White Corn

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

King Arthur Whole Wheat

150

6

15

6

1.65

170

Table 1: Composition of whole colored corn and whole wheat E. cava flatbreads (g).

Flatbread

Flour

Guar Gum

Ecklonia cava

Olive oil

Salt

Water

Whole Blue Corn

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

Purell Whole Blue Corn

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

Purell Whole Red Corn

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

Purell Whole Yellow Corn

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

Purell Whole White Corn

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

Purell Whole Giant White Corn

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

King Arthur Wholewheat

43.02

1.72

4.30

1.72

0.47

48.7

Table 2: Composition of whole colored corn and whole wheat E. cava flatbreads (%).

Ingredients

Protein

Fat

Minerals

Carbohydrates

Dry matter

Water

Whole Blue Corn

6.43±0.02d

14.01±0.12a

1.18±0.01e

68.29±0.12f

89.91±0.09c

10.09±0.09f

Purell Whole Blue Corn

6.49±0.01d

12.43±0.17b

1.31±0.01c

69.57±0.30e

89.80±0.07d

10.20±0.07e

Purell Whole Red Corn

8.65±0.06b

11.03±0.42e

1.26±0.04d

67.81±0.36g

88.75±0.05g

11.25±0.05b

Purell Whole Yellow Corn

5.81±0.04e

11.46±0.29d

1.16±0.01e

69.96±0.34d

88.39±0.02h

11.61±0.02a

Purell Whole White Corn

6.82±0.06c

10.39±0.02f

1.19±0.03e

71.75±0.07b

91.15±0.02b

9.85±0.02g

Purell Whole Giant White

Corn

5.19±0.05f

12.16±0.26c

1.51±0.04b

70.06±0.07c

88.92±0.10f

11.08±0.10c

King Arthur Whole Wheat

15.14±0.34a

4.43±0010g

2.37±0.06a

67.43±0.35h

89.37±0.10e

10.63±0.10d

Ecklonia cava

2.17±0.02g

1.27±0.13h

1.09±0.09f

91.17±0.16a

95.70±0.03a

4.31±0.03g

Values with different superscript letters differ significantly (p ≤0.05), n=3. Colored corn data from [5].

Table 3: Proximate composition of colored corn, wheat and E. cava ingredients, on a dry matter basis, mean ± SD.(%).

Ingredients

Protein

Fat

Minerals

Carbohydrate

Dry Matter

Water

Whole Blue Corn

7.32±0.02d

4.69±0.10d

1.82±0.02d

47.29±0.81a

61.11±0.72b

38.89±0.72c

Purell Whole Blue Corn

7.36±0.11d

4.92±0.76d

2.04±0.04c

47.02±0.84a

61.34±0.72b

38.66±0.72c

Purell Whole Red Corn

9.78±0.05b

6.67±0.12a

1.87±0.13d

44.95±1.66c

62.87±1.61a

37.13±1.61d

Purell Whole Yellow Corn

6.43±0.32e

5.46±0.11c

1.80±0.28d

46.34±0.59ab

60.02±0.40c

39.98±0.40b

Purell Whole White Corn

7.65±0.06c

5.73±0.08b

1.78±0.04d

46.21±0.14b

61.37±0.13b

38.63±0.13c

Purell Whole Giant White Corn

6.01±0.02f

6.32±0.15a

2.20±0.08b

43.85±0.16d

58.37±0.08d

41.63±0.08a

King Arthur Whole Wheat

5.35±0.12g

3.81±0.12e

2.37±0.06a

40.23±0.93e

61.77±0.73b

38.23±0.73c

Values with different superscript letters differ significantly (p ≤0.05), n=3.

Table 4: Composition of colored corn E. Cava flatbreads on a dry matter basis (%), mean ± SD.

Flatbreads

Corn

Ecklonia

Corn

Protein

Corn-Ecklonia

Protein

Protein

Change

Change

%

Blue Corn-EC

38.68

4.3

7.15

11.98

4.83

67.49

Purcell Blue Corn-EC

38.18

4.3

7.23

12.00

4.77

66.02

Purcell Red Corn-EC

38.18

4.3

9.75

15.56

5.81

59.61

Purcell Yellow Corn-EC

38.03

4.3

6.57

10.71

4.14

62.98

Purcell White Corn-EC

38.78

4.3

7.57

12.47

4.90

64.77

Giant White Corn-EC

38.25

4.3

5.84

10.30

4.46

76.41

King Arthur Wheat-EC

38.45

4.3

16.95

24.85

7.90

46.59

Corn protein from ingredients in Table 3, Kjeldahl determination for protein = (N x 6.25), n=3.

Table 5. Change in protein content in flatbreads with the addition E. cava (EC) on a dry matter basis (g).

Ingredients

Corn

Guar

Gum

Ecklonia

Total

Corn-Ecklonia

FB change

Change %

Whole Blue Corn

2.487

0.839

0.089

3.415

4.473

1.058

30.986

Purcell Whole Blue Corn

2.507

0.839

0.089

3.435

4.515

1.079

31.423

Purcell Whole Red Corn

3.303

0.839

0.089

4.231

6.149

1.918

45.340

Purcell Whole Yellow Corn

2.209

0.839

0.089

3.137

3.859

0.722

23.015

Purcell Whole White Corn

2.645

0.839

0.089

3.753

4.695

1.122

31.399

Purcell Whole Giant White

Corn

1.985

0.839

0.089

2.913

3.508

0.595

20.414

King Arthur Whole Wheat

5.821

0.839

0.089

6.749

9.482

2.733

40.4994

Data calculated from Tables 2, 3 and 4 except Guar Gum. Guar Gum data from [6].

Table 6:  Protein content of flatbread  ingredients and corn-Ecklonia flatbread (g).

Ingredients

Corn

Guar Gum

Ecklonia

Olive Oil

Total

Corn-Ecklonia

FB change

Change

(%)

Whole Blue Corn

5.419

0.037

0.052

1.72

7.728

2.866

-4.362

-60.347

Purcell Whole Blue Corn

4.802

0.037

0.052

1.72

6.611

3.018

-3.593

-54.349

Purcell Whole Red Corn

4.211

0.037

0.052

1.72

6.020

3.942

-2.078

-34.521

Purcell Whole Yellow

Corn

4.358

0.037

0.052

1.72

6.167

3.277

-2.890

-46.858

Purcell Whole White

Corn

4.030

0.037

0.052

1.72

5.838

3.517

-2.322

-39.770

Purcell Whole Giant

White Corn

4.652

0.037

0.052

1.72

6.461

3.689

-2.772

-42.900

King Arthur whole wheat

1.703

0.037

0.052

1.72

3.512

2.353

-1.159

-32.991

Data calculated from Tables 2, 3 and 4 except Guar Gum. Guar Gum data from [6].

Table 7: Fat content of flatbread ingredients and Corn-Ecklonia flatbread (g).

Ingredients

Corn

Guar Gum

Ecklonia

Salt

Total

Corn-Ecklonia

FB change

Change

(%)

Whole Blue Corn

0.456

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.048

1.112

0.064

6.146

Purcell Whole Blue Corn

0.506

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.097

1.251

0.154

14.020

Purcell Whole Red Corn

0.481

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.072

1.176

0.103

9.624

Purcell Whole Yellow Corn

0.441

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.032

1.080

0.048

4.637

Purcell Whole White Corn

0.462

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.053

1.092

0.039

3.750

Purcell Whole Giant White

Corn

0.578

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.169

1.284

0.115

9.848

King Arthur Whole Wheat

0.912

0.077

0.045

0.47

1.503

1.464

0.039

2.571

Data calculated from Tables 2, 3 and 4 except Guar Gum. Guar Gum data from [6].

Table 8. Mineral content of flatbread Ingredients and corn-Ecklonia flatbread (g).

Ingredients

Corn

Guar Gum

Ecklonia

Total

Corn-Ecklonia

FB change

Change (%)

Whole Blue Corn

26.414

0.526

3.752

30.672

28.899

-1.793

-5.842

Purcell Whole Blue Corn

26.876

0.526

3.752

31.154

28.842

-2.312

-7.421

Purcell Whole Red Corn

25.890

0.526

3.752

30.168

28.260

-1.908

-6.324

Purcell Whole Yellow Corn

26.603

0.526

3.752

30.880

27.813

-3.067

-9.332

Purcell Whole White Corn

27.826

0.526

3.752

32.104

28.359

-3.745

-11.666

Table 9. Carbohydrate content of flatbread ingredients and corn-Ecklonia flatbread (g).

Ingredients

Corn

Guar Gum

Ecklonia

Olive oil

Salt

Total

Corn- Ecklonia

FB change

Change (%)

Whole Blue Corn

34.777

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

42.383

37.350

-5.032

-11.873

Purcell Whole Blue Corn

34.692

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

42.298

37.626

-4.672

-11.045

Purcell Whole Red Corn

33.885

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

41.491

39.526

-1.965

-4.735

Purcell Whole Yellow Corn

33.611

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

41.217

36.030

-5.186

-12.584

Purcell Whole White Corn

34.962

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

42.569

37.663

-4.906

-11.525

Purcell Whole Giant White Corn

34.015

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

41.621

34.076

-7.545

-18.127

King Arthur Whole Wheat

34.360

1.478

3.938

1.72

0.47

41.966

38.149

-3.817

-9.096

Data calculated from Tables 2, 3 and 4 except Guar Gum. Guar Gum data from [6].

Table 10. Dry matter content of flatbread ingredients and corn-Ecklonia flatbread (g).

Ingredients

Corn

Guar

Gum

Ecklonia

Water

Total

Corn-

Ecklonia

FB change

Change (%)

Whole Blue Corn

3.903

0.116

0.177

48.7

52.896

62.650

9.753

18.438

Purcell Whole Blue Corn

3.940

0.116

0.177

48.7

52.934

62.374

9.440

17.833

Purcell Whole Red Corn

4.295

0.116

0.177

48.7

53.289

60.474

7.185

13.482

Purcell Whole Yellow Corn

4.415

0.116

0.177

48.7

53.409

63.970

10.561

19.775

Purcell Whole White Corn

3.820

0.116

0.177

48.7

52.814

62.337

9.523

18.032

Purcell Whole Giant White

Corn

4.238

0.116

0.177

48.7

53.232

65.924

12.691

23.842

King Arthur Whole Wheat

4.087

0.116

0.177

48.3

53.081

61.581

8.770

16.522

Data calculated from Tables 2, 3 and 4 except Guar Gum. Guar Gum data from [6].

Table 11. Water content of flatbread ingredients and corn-Ecklonia flatbread (g).

Discussion

Safety Aspects

Highlights from the literature seem to show that E. cava and bioactive compounds have a high order of safety in humans and rodents. An oral toxicity study by the European EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition, and Allergies (NDA) reported that phlorotannins from E. cava are safe for use in food supplements at a maximum intake level of 163 mg/day for adolescents 12 to 14 years of age, 230 mg/day for adolescents above 14 years of age, and 263 mg/day for adults [7]. Based on subchronic oral toxicity and genotoxicity studies in rats and dogs, Yun et al. [8] reported that the no-observed-adverse-effect level of E. cava was 3000 mg/kg/day for male and female rats; and that it was not mutagenic or clastogenic (chromosomedamaging). A review by Javed et al. [9] on the pharmacology of phlorotannins concluded that their curative functions could be attributed to their antioxidant properties.

Health Benefits of Colored Corn and Ecklonia cava

Colored corns and E. cava alga and their bioactive components have been shown to have multiple health benefits in cells and rodents, including anti-Alzheimer disease, antibiotic, anti-viral, anti-anxiety, anti-cancer, anti-cognitive decline, antidiabetes, anti-obesity, anti-constipation, anti-hearing loss, antihypertension, anti-insomnia, anti-neurodegeneration, anti-ovarian dysfunction, anti-periodontitis, and anti-photo-ageing of the skin effects. To facilitate much needed human studies on one or more of these benefits of the new flatbreads that contain both these flours and the alga, we will highlight selected research to stimulate further studies on the potential benefits of these flatbreads.

Colored Corn Flours

Here, we briefly summarize the reported contents of bioactive antioxidative phenolic compounds in colored flours that are expected to contribute to the health benefits of the flatbreads. Ranilla et al. [10] reported on the content of bioactive compounds in white, orange, and red Peruvian corn harvested at different stages of maturity. All maize types contained free hydroxybenzoic and hydroxycinnamic acids and bounds ferulic acid, ferulic acid derivatives, and p-coumaric acid. Luteolin and anthocyanin flavonoids were present only in the orange and red samples. Xanthophylls (lutein, zeaxanthin, neoxanthin, and lutein isomer) were present in all maize types. In related studies, Chatham and Juvik [11] and Paulsmeyer et al. [12] evaluated anthocyanin diversity in purple corns, and Zhu et al. [13] related anthocyanin levels in maize, rice, wheat, barley, sorghum, millet, and rye to reported health effects that include anti-oxidation, anti-cancer, glycemic and body weight regulation, neuroprotection, retinal protection, hypolipidemia, hepatoprotection, and anti-ageing effects. A review by Ngamsamer et al. [14] suggests that that the consumption of anthocyanin-rich foods can protect against obesityinduced inflammation. Finally, Aguirre Lopez et al. [15] found that consuming an anthocyanin extract or anthocyanin-containing tortillas made with blue corn decreased anxiety-like behavior and improved learning and memory in a chronic rat stress model, suggesting the value of the blue tortillas as a potential functional food. Will flatbreads prepared from blue corn show similar health benefits?

Choi et al. [16] showed that the combination of the compound eckol isolated from E. cava and the medicinal drug ampicillin acted synergistically against the foodborne pathogens Staphylococcus aureus and Salmonella spp., suggesting the compound has potential for inhibiting the growth of these bacteria on contaminated food and in infected animals and humans. Kwon et al. [17] reported that phlorotannins isolated from E. cava inhibited porcine epidemic diarrhea coronavirus in vitro, a virus that causes a high mortality rate in piglets. Karadeniz et al. [18] reported that a phlorotannin derivative inhibited HIV-1 activty and Cho et al. [19] used mass spectrometry to determine antiviral activities of phlorotannins from E. cava.

Lee et al. [1] obtained a new functional food by bioprocessing (fermenting) E. cava with shiitake mushroom mycelia that protected mice against ovalbumin-induced allergic asthma. The new functional food also reversed the thickening of the airway wall and infiltration of bronchial and blood vessels and inflammatory cells. In addition to ameliorating adverse effects of asthma, the novel food product might have other therapeutic uses in humans including prevention of peanut protein and other food allergies.

Fucoidan, extracted from E. cava, was shown by Zhang et al. [20] to induce anti-metastatic lung cancer immunity when administered intranasally in mice. Additional data suggest that the fucoidan extract functioned as a mucosal adjuvant that enhanced the immunotherapeutic effect of immune checkpoint inhibitors against lung cancer. A review by Jin et al. [21] collates information on molecular and cellular aspects and anti-cancer effects fucoidan, a natural marine anticancer agent.

Dieckol from E. cava has also been shown to have therapeutic effects. For example, Lu et al. [22] reported that dieckol isolated from E. cava promoted blood flow velocity and vasodilation of blood vessels in zebra fish by enlarging the dorsal aorta diameter, suggesting its potential clinical use as a vasodilator. In related studies, Oh et al. [23] found that dieckol reduces muscle atrophy in hypertensive rats and Byun et al. [24] discovered that E. cava extracts decreased hypertension-related vascular calcification.

Cho et al. [25] found that dieckol isolated from E. cava inhibited advanced glycation end products associated with the pathogenesis of diabetic nephropathy in mouse glomerular mesangial cells, suggesting dieckol might have the potential to treat diabetic nephropathy in humans. A related study by Hwang et al. [26] reported that phloroglucinol and dieckol suppressed angiogenesis in diabetic vascular complications. Almutairi et al. [27] reported that administering 600 mg of polyphenolic-rich E. cava extract to 20 Saudi Arabian prediabetic patients for up to 120 min reduced the postprandial blood glucose level with no associated side effects.

Park et al. [28] discovered, using a behavioral test, that a water extract of E. cava effectively prevented learning and memory declines in mice caused by pollution-induced neurotoxicity. The extract also improved oxidative damage of the lungs and brain and regulated cognition-related proteins. It decreased amyloid precursor protein (APP) and p-Tau and increased Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF) associated with induced cognitive dysfunction. The bioactive compound in the extract consisted of a polysaccharide and phenolic compounds. Jo et al. [29] reported that an E. cava extract decreased the activity of biomarkers association with inflammation as well as with neurodegenerative disease in the cerebellum and hippocampus of mice, suggesting the extract might protect against neuroinflammation and neurodegenerative diseases. Yang et al. [30,31] found that phloroglucinol, a component of E. cava, inhibited the generation of cell-damaging Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) in astrocytes, the most abundant cell types of the Central Nervous System (CNS). The compound also ameliorated the expression of glial fibrillary acidic protein, a marker of reactive astrocytes, suggesting its potential value against Alzheimer’s disease and Kwon et al. [32] used ophlorotannins to treat neurodegenerative disorders.

There are many other reported wide-ranging health benefits for E. cava extracts or fractions. For example, a review by Kim et al. (2023) states that the Korean Ministry of Food and Drug Safety approved the use of an E. cava supplement containing phlorotannin as a health-functional product that helps improve sleep quality. The paper covers the sedative-hypnotic mechanisms in animal models as well as human clinical trials.

 In addition, fucoidan fractions isolated from E. cava remarkably reduced lipid accumulation in 3T3-Ll adipocyte cells and significantly reduced body weight gain, serum and liver lipid contents, and white adipose tissue mass in mice on a high-fat diet, suggesting that the anti-obesity extracts could be used in food [33]. Abbas et al. [34] observed similar results with a 70% E. cava extract orally administered to rats, suggesting the extract also represents a potential candidate for the prevention of obesity. A mass spectrometry-based metabolomics analysis of urine samples of individuals after consumption of seapolynol isolated from E. cava shows that decreased body fat is related to an increase in the antioxidant effect of riboflavin, which was associated with the Body Mass Index (BMI), body weight, fat mass, and percent body fat [35].

In another application, He et al. [36] reported that 6,6’-bieckol from E. cava reduced UVB radiation-induced oxidative stress damage in human immortalized keratinocyte cells, suggesting its potential value as a functional food and skin care ingredient that might prevent photo-ageing damage of human skin caused by UVB-radiation from the sun. In oral health, Jung et al. [37] showed that applying an E. cava extract to Lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated Human Gingival Fibroblasts (HGF-I) in mice mitigated gingival tissue destruction and bone resorption associated with chronic oral disease. Reproductive effects have also been observed. Yang et al. [38] found that E. cava extracts restored ovarian dysfunction and anti-inflammatory responses in rats with PCOS-like symptoms, suggesting its potential value to treat ovarian failure. Li et al. [39] found that administering the E. cava component dieckol to the inner ear of rats prevented ototoxic hearing loss, suggesting that the procedure may be a safe and effective method to prevent drug-induced hearing loss. Park et al. [40] reported that a water extract of E. cava acts as a potential therapeutic agent against fine dust induced health damage in mice by regulating gut function of the microbiota and Kim et al. [41] provides evidence for the use of phlorotannin against constipation in rats. 

The cited observations on the actual and potential health benefits of’ the colored corn flours, the Ecklonia cava alga, and the new flatbreads containing both ingredients suggest the need for clinicians to translate the described health benefits in animal models to human therapies.

Conclusions

The Ecklonia cava alga widely consumed in Asian countries as a medicinal food is now available from commercial sources in the United States. To demonstrate therapeutic applications, the described potential health benefits of Ecklonia cava-containing flatbreads need to be confirmed by studies with human patients to determine their value to ameliorate, prevent, and treat human diseases. Moreover, the newly colored-corn-based flatbreads can contribute additional benefits in the diet that can result in additive or synergistic effects after consumption. These include: (a) preparation from whole grains reported to have cardioprotective effects compared to refined grains; (b) the use of olive oil in the recipe that contains unsaturated fats reported to reduce the incidence of cardiovascular disease [42]; and (c) the lack of gluten that can benefit consumers that are allergic to its adverse effects. These highlights reinforce the need for commercial and home production of the flatbreads that requires only a 2-min baking step. Finally, because the amino acid tryptophan is nutritionally limiting in corn [43,44] and is transformed to serotonin that benefits cognitive function, we are also challenged to prepare flatbreads using high-tryptophan, as well as high-lysine, corn that will be expected to show improved nutrition and health benefits.

References

  1. Lee KH, Jang YJ, Hwang WS, Kwon KS, et al. (2022) Edible Algae (Ecklonia Cava) Bioprocessed with Mycelia of Shiitake (Lentinula Edodes) Mushrooms in Liquid Culture and Its Isolated Fractions Protect Mice against Allergic Asthma. BMC Complement Med Ther 22: 242.
  2. Crawford LM, Kahlon TS, Wang SC, Friedman M (2019)  Acrylamide Content of Experimental Flatbreads Prepared from Potato, Quinoa, and Wheat Flours with Added Fruit and Vegetable Peels and Mushroom Powders. Foods 8: 228.
  3. Crawford LM, Kahlon TS, Chiu MCM, Wang SC, Friedman M (2019) Acrylamide Content of Experimental and Commercial Flatbreads. J Food Sci 84: 659-666.
  4. Li X, Kahlon T, Wang SC, Friedman M (2021) Low Acrylamide Flatbreads Prepared from Colored Rice Flours and Relationship to Asparagine and Proximate Content of Flours and Flatbreads. Foods 10: 2909.
  5. Li X, Kahlon T, Wang SC, Friedman M (2021) Low Acrylamide Flatbreads from Colored Corn and Other Flours. Foods 10: 2495.
  6. Ahmed M, Hamid R, Ali M, Hassan A, Babiker E (2006) Proximate Composition, Antinutritional Factors and Protein Fractions of Guar Gum Seeds as Influenced by Processing Treatments. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition 5: 481-484.
  7. EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA), Turck D, Bresson JL, Burlingame B, Dean T, Fairweather-Tait S, et al. (2017) Safety of Ecklonia Cava Phlorotannins as a Novel Food Pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 258/97. EFSA Journal 15: e05003.
  8. Yun JW, Kim SH, Kim YS, You JR, Cho EY, et al. (2018) Enzymatic Extract from Ecklonia Cava: Acute and Subchronic Oral Toxicity and Genotoxicity Studies. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 92: 46–54.
  9. Javed A, Hussain MB, Tahir A, Waheed M, Anwar A, et al. (2021) Pharmacological Applications of Phlorotannins: A Comprehensive Review. Curr Drug Discov Technol 18: 282–292.
  10. Ranilla LG, Zolla G, Afaray-Carazas A, Vera-Vega M, Huanuqueño H et al. (2023) Integrated Metabolite Analysis and Health-Relevant in Vitro Functionality of White, Red, and Orange Maize (Zea Mays L.) from the Peruvian Andean Race Cabanita at Different Maturity Stages. Frontiers in Nutrition 10: 1132228.
  11. Chatham LA, Juvik JA (2021) Linking Anthocyanin Diversity, Hue, and Genetics in Purple Corn. G3 Genes|Genomes|Genetics 11: jkaa062.
  12. Paulsmeyer MN, Vermillion KE, Juvik JA (2022) Assessing the Diversity of Anthocyanin Composition in Various Tissues of Purple Corn (Zea Mays L.). Phytochemistry 201: 113263.
  13. Zhu F (2018) Anthocyanins in Cereals: Composition and Health Effects. Food Res Int 109: 232–249.
  14. Ngamsamer C, Sirivarasai J, Sutjarit N (2022) The Benefits of Anthocyanins against Obesity-Induced Inflammation. Biomolecules 12: 852.
  15. Aguirre López LO, Cuéllar Pérez JR, Santerre A, Moreno YS, Hernández De Anda Y, et al. (2022) Effect of Consumption of Blue Maize Tortilla on Anxiety-like Behaviour, Learning, Memory and Hippocampal BDNF Expression in a Chronic Stress Model in Rats. Nutr Neurosci 26: 1058–1067.
  16. Choi JG, Kang OH, Brice OO, Lee YS, Chae HS, et al. (2010) Antibacterial Activity of Ecklonia Cava against Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus Aureus and Salmonella Spp. Foodborne Pathog Dis 7: 435–441.
  17. Kwon HJ, Ryu YB, Kim YM, Song N, Kim CY, et al. (2013) In VitroAntiviral Activity of Phlorotannins Isolated from Ecklonia Cavaagainst Porcine Epidemic Diarrhea Coronavirus Infection and Hemagglutination. Bioorg Med Chem 21: 4706–4713.
  18. Karadeniz F, Kang KH, Park JW, Park SJ, Kim SK (2014) Anti-HIV-1 Activity of Phlorotannin Derivative 8,4‴-Dieckol from Korean Brown Alga Ecklonia Cava. Biosci. Biotechnol. Biochem 78: 1151–1158.
  19. Cho HM, Doan TP, Ha TKQ, Kim HW, Lee BW, et al. (2019) Dereplication by High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) with Quadrupole-Time-of-Flight Mass Spectroscopy (QTOF-MS) and Antiviral Activities of Phlorotannins from Ecklonia Cava. Mar Drugs 17: 149.
  20. Zhang W, Hwang J, Yadav D, An EK, Kwak M, et al. (2021) Enhancement of Immune Checkpoint Inhibitor-Mediated Anti-Cancer Immunity by Intranasal Treatment of Ecklonia Cava Fucoidan against Metastatic Lung Cancer. Int J Mol Sci 22: 9125.
  21. Jin JO, Chauhan PS, Arukha AP, Chavda V, Dubey A, et al. (2021) The Therapeutic Potential of the Anticancer Activity of Fucoidan: Current Advances and Hurdles. Mar. Drugs 19: 265.
  22. Lu YA, Je JG, Hwang J, Jeon YJ, Ryu B (2021) Ecklonia CavaExtract and Its Derivative Dieckol Promote Vasodilation by Modulating Calcium Signaling and PI3K/AKT/ENOS Pathway in In Vitro and In Vivo Models. Biomedicines 9: 438.
  23. Oh S, Yang JY, Park CH, Son KH, Byun K (2021) Dieckol Reduces Muscle Atrophy by Modulating Angiotensin Type II Type 1 Receptor and NADPH Oxidase in Spontaneously Hypertensive Rats. Antioxidants (Basel) 10:  1561.
  24. Byun KA, Oh S, Yang JY, Lee SY, Son KH, Byun K (2022) Ecklonia Cava Extracts Decrease Hypertension-Related Vascular Calcification by Modulating PGC-1α and SOD2. Biomed. Pharmacother 153: 113283.
  25. Cho CH, Yoo G, Kim M, Kurniawati UD, Choi IW, et al. (2023) Dieckol, Derived from the Edible Brown Algae Ecklonia Cava, Attenuates Methylglyoxal-Associated Diabetic Nephropathy by Suppressing AGERAGE Interaction. Antioxidants (Basel) 12: 593.
  26. Hwang J, Yang HW, Lu YA, Je JG, Lee HG, et al. (2021) Phloroglucinol and Dieckol Isolated from Ecklonia Cava Suppress Impaired Diabetic Angiogenesis; A Study of in-Vitro and in-Vivo. Biomed. Pharmacother 138: 111431.
  27. Almutairi MG, Aldubayan K, Molla H (2023) Effect of Seaweed (Ecklonia Cava Extract) on Blood Glucose and Insulin Level on Prediabetic Patients: A Double-Blind Randomized Controlled Trial. Food Sci Nutr 11: 983–990.
  28. Park SK, Kang JY, Kim JM, Kim HJ, Heo HJ (2021) Ecklonia CavaAttenuates PM2.5-Induced Cognitive Decline through Mitochondrial Activation and Anti-Inflammatory Effect. Mar Drugs 19: 131.
  29. Jo SL, Yang H, Jeong KJ, Lee HW, Hong EJ (2023) Neuroprotective Effects of Ecklonia Cava in a Chronic Neuroinflammatory Disease Model. Nutrients 15: 2007.
  30. Yang EJ, Ahn S, Ryu J, Choi MS, Choi S, et al. (2015) Phloroglucinol Attenuates the Cognitive Deficits of the 5XFAD Mouse Model of Alzheimer’s Disease. PLoS One 10: e0135686.
  31. Yang EJ, Kim H, Kim HS, Chang MJ (2021) Phloroglucinol Attenuates Oligomeric Amyloid Beta Peptide1-42-Induced Astrocytic Activation by Reducing Oxidative Stress. J Pharmacol Sci 145: 308–312.
  32. Kwon YJ, Kwon OI, Hwang HJ, Shin HC, Yang S (2023) Therapeutic Effects of Phlorotannins in the Treatment of Neurodegenerative Disorders. Front Mol Neurosci 16: 1193590.
  33. Lee HG, Jayawardena TU, Song KM, Choi YS, Jeon YJ, et al. (2022) Dietary Fucoidan from a Brown Marine Algae (Ecklonia Cava) Attenuates Lipid Accumulation in Differentiated 3T3-L1 Cells and Alleviates High-Fat Diet-Induced Obesity in Mice. Food Chem Toxicol 162: 112862.
  34. Abbas MA, Boby N, Lee EB, Hong JH, Park SC (2022) Anti-Obesity Effects of Ecklonia Cava Extract in High-Fat Diet-Induced Obese Rats. Antioxidants (Basel) 11: 310.
  35. Kim J, Jung Y, Lee E, Jang S, Ryu DH, Kwon O et al. (2020) Urinary Metabolomic Profiling Analysis and Evaluation of the Effect of Ecklonia Cava Extract Intake. Nutrients 12: 1407.
  36. He YL, Xiao Z, Yang S, Zhou C, Sun S, et al. (2022) A Phlorotanin, 6,6′-Bieckol from Ecklonia Cava, Against Photoaging by Inhibiting MMP-1, -3 and -9 Expression on UVB-Induced HaCaT Keratinocytes. Photochemistry and Photobiology 98: 1131–1139.
  37. Jung JI, Kim S, Baek SM, Choi SI, Kim GH, et al. (2021) Ecklonia Cava Extract Exerts Anti-Inflammatory Effect in Human Gingival Fibroblasts and Chronic Periodontitis Animal Model by Suppression of Pro-Inflammatory Cytokines and Chemokines. Foods 10: 1656.
  38. Yang H, Lee SR, Jo SL, Kim AH, Kim ER, et al. (2022) The Improvement Effect of D-Chiro-Inositol and Ecklonia Cava K. in the Rat Model of Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome. Front Pharmacol 13: 905191.
  39. Li H, Oh SH, Shin HC, Suh MW (2022) Intratympanic Administration of Dieckol Prevents Ototoxic Hearing Loss. Mar. Drugs 20: 622.
  40. Park SK, Kang JY, Kim JM Kim MJ, Lee HL, et al. (2022) Water Extract of Ecklonia Cava Protects against Fine Dust (PM2.5)-Induced Health Damage by Regulating Gut Health. J Microbiol Biotechnol 32: 927– 937.
  41. Kim JE, Song HJ, Choi YJ, Jin YJ, Roh YJ, et al. (2023) Improvement of the Intestinal Epithelial Barrier during Laxative Effects of Phlorotannin in Loperamide-Induced Constipation of SD Rats. Lab Anim Res 39: 1.
  42. Kiani AK, Medori MC, Bonetti G, Aquilanti B, Velluti V, et al. (2022) Modern Vision of the Mediterranean Diet. J Prev Med Hyg 63: E36– E43.
  43. Friedman M (2018) Analysis, Nutrition, and Health Benefits of Tryptophan. Int J Tryptophan Res 11: 1178646918802282.
  44. Cuq JL (1989) Effect of Heat on Tryptophan in Food: Chemistry, Toxicology, and Nutritional Consequences. In Friedman. M. (ed.) Absorption and Utilization of Amino Acids; CRC Press, ISBN 978-1351-06944-1.

© by the Authors & Gavin Publishers. This is an Open Access Journal Article Published Under Attribution-Share Alike CC BY-SA: Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International License. With this license, readers can share, distribute, download, even commercially, as long as the original source is properly cited. Read More About Open Access Policy.

Food & Nutrition Journal

Update cookies preferences