Assessment of Endothelial Cell Proliferation and Adhesion Strength on Decellularized Bovine Pericardial Scaffolds for Tissue Engineering
Pagoulatou
Eirini, Mavrilas Dimosthenis*
Department of Mechanical Engineering and Aeronautics, University of
Patras, Greece
*Corresponding
author: Mavrilas
Dimosthenis, Laboratory
of Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, Department of Mechanical
Engineering and Aeronautics, University of Patras, 26500 Patras, Greece. Tel: +302610969488;
Fax: +302610969464; Email: dmauril@upatras.gr
Received
Date: 19 September, 2018; Accepted
Date: 11 October, 2018; Published Date: 19 October, 2018
Citation: Pagoulatou E, Mavrilas D (2018) Assessment of Endothelial Cell Proliferation and Adhesion Strength on Decellularized Bovine Pericardial Scaffolds for Tissue Engineering. Curr Res Regen Med Tissue Eng: CRRT-104. DOI: 10.29011/CRRT -104. 100004
1. Abstract
Decellularized animal tissues are attractive sources of scaffolds for tissue engineering applications. Their natural extracellular matrix is an interesting substrate for cell emigration, infiltration and attachment in vivo, enhancing cell function for the formation of new natural living tissue. In this work we investigated the role of the decellularization protocols in successful cell growth and attachment strength on the surface of de cell decell animal tissues. For this purpose, we cultured bovine aortic endothelial cells on previously decellularized bovine pericardial tissues according to three different protocols. Microscopic analysis and application of shear stress on the scaffold surface was used for the assessment of cell growth and attachment strength. The results showed that the combination of mechanical force with detergent decellularization was superior compared with the enzymatic decellularization regarding cell proliferation on the scaffolds’ surface. Cell attachment strength was satisfactory, even in high physiological stress levels. In conclusion, decellularized animal tissue can be considered as suitable scaffolds for tissue engineering.
2. Keywords: Cell Proliferation; Cell ECM Attachment; Decellularized Scaffolds
3.
Introduction
The design of an
ideal scaffold for Tissue Engineering (TE) has met the challenge of mimicking
the extracellular matrix in composition and Micro-Nano topography, providing an
increased speed in functional tissue regeneration or recovery of damaged
tissues through supportive cell adhesion under appropriate guidance and cell
signaling in vivo.
Cells
within living tissues are surrounded by Extra Cellular Matrix (ECM) that
supports cell adhesion via integrin receptors. In TE scaffolds, the ability of
seeded cells to adhere to scaffold material is of paramount importance for
potential regenerative cell response to biomechanical stimulation.
Cell-implant
adhesive strength is a focused point in tissue engineering. Cells in physiological body circulation are subjected to varied mechanical
stress fields including gravitational force, mechanical stretch or strain and
shear stress. Due to the pulsatile nature of blood flow, blood vessels are
subjected to significant variations in mechanical forces. The main challenge in
TE scaffolds for vascular repair is the presence, integrity and state of
endothelium lining at the implant - host interface [1-5].
Endothelial cells attached on the blood contacting scaffold surface (like heart
valve leaflets or the lumen of blood vessel walls) function as an interface
between blood and scaffold material. They play a crucial role as barriers for
blood component interactions with scaffold and also detecting and responding to
the mechanical forces generated by shear stress due to blood flow and
scaffold’s mechanical resistance. Shear stress can modulate endothelial cell
functions by sequentially activating specific transcription factors, and the
expression of genes and proteins [6,7]. Normal
wall shear stress (1.5-2.5 Pa) promotes a quiescent endothelial cell state,
suppressing proliferation, inflammation and apoptosis while promoting a
protective anti-thrombotic and selective permeability barrier [1,4]. The effects of externally applied shear forces
have been used to determine the cell adhesion strength for cells attached to Extra
Cellular Matrix (ECM) surface [7-9]. ln
addition, activation of endothelial cells on biomaterials leads to expression
of new adhesion molecules on their surface, controls the transfer of molecules
and interacts with underlying cells to regulate their growth potential and
proliferation [5,10]. Oppositely, dysfunctional
endothelial cells promote inflammatory reactions, resulting therefore to
scaffold/biomaterial rejection [10,11].
Cell adhesion and
proliferation depend on the formation of the fibrous components and functional
complexes of ECM [12-18]. Collagen receptors and
collagen binding molecules [19], elastin
peptides [20] and Glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) [21-25] seem to be responsible for chemotaxis, for
organizing the ECM and for cellular communication. Treatment of allogenic
biomaterials for decellularization to be used as implants in humans may highly
preserve the structural integrity of many ECM proteins and is thus currently
utilized for soft tissue repair applications.
Among the different strategies in the field of scaffold design for
cardiovascular tissue engineering, our basic approach is focused to the use of
decellularized allogeneic materials with structural similarity to the native
cardiovascular tissues. Decellularized bovine pericardium was selected as a
candidate for producing cardiovascular scaffolds, due to its successful behavior
under dynamic mechanical loading and blood interaction in vivo after
a long time use as bioprosthetic
biomaterial. Biomechanical performance, structural integrity and composition of
ECM, especially Glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) content, seemed to be preserved after
decellularization using detergent treatment, as alternative to enzymatic
decellularization. Endothelial cell survival and proliferation were also
enhanced, as proved by in vitro cell culture studies [26].
Cell attachment on biomaterial surfaces has been extensively studied by
measuring the detachment strength of cells from the surfaces, using two
experimental methodologies: parallel plate flow chambers [27,28] or rotating disc/flow devices [29,30]. The spinning disc provided a more
quantitative assay for the determination of cell adhesion, demonstrating a
linear relationship between the force necessary to detach cells and the number
of adhesive bonds [9,29].
The aim of this work was to explore cell - ECM interactions of Bovine Aortic
Endothelial Cells (BAEC) attached on decellularized Bovine Pericardial (BP)
tissues by quantifying the adhesion strength, as determined by exposing cells
seeded on acellular BP surface to a shear stress field and measuring the cells
remained attached. The
adhesion and proliferation of cells on acellular BP were characterized by
fluorescence and scanning electron microscopy. A spinning disc device was used to produce the shear
forces field applied to the cells. Cell detachment was detected and compared
with different commercially available acellular biomaterials.
4.
Materials and Methods
4.1. A General Description of Bio Scaffolds
The method of decellularization for bovine pericardium has been described
previously [26]. In brief, fresh BP obtained
from the local slaughterhouse was decellularized by the detergent and enzyme
extraction method. For the former method, the pericardium was incubated in
hypotonic buffer (2D distilled water) for 2 hours at 4°C and subsequently in hypertonic Tris buffer
with 1%
Triton® X–100 (AppliChem), 0.1% SDS (Merck), 150mM NaCl (Merck), 1%
deoxycholic acid (AppliChem) and protease
inhibitor (P1860 - Sigma Aldrich) at 4°C for 12 hours. In enzymatic decellularization method, BP was
agitated in Tris buffer with 20 μg/ml RNase and 0.2
mg/ml DNase (Applichem) in Trypsin/EDTA hypotonic Tris buffer solution (0.5 %/0.2 %, 10mM Tris, pH
7.5) for
48 hours at 37°C. Finally, treated acellular BP under both modes was washed with PBS
followed by cell culture.
In addition to tissues treated using the
above-mentioned protocols, commercially available acellular bovine pericardial
patches for abdominal and vaginal wall (Synovis - Veritas Collagen Matrix) [31], kindly supplied by the company, were
comparatively cultured.
4.2. Preparation of Cell Culture
For the study of
the cell–material interactions, BAEC cell line ΒW-6001 (Lonza) was used. The cells were cultured in 25 cm2 culture flasks in Dubelcco’s Modified Eagle’s
Medium (DMEM - Biochrom) with 10% Fetal Bovine Serum (FBS - Biochrom) and 1%
antibiotics (streptomycin and penicillin - Biochrom) at 37°C with 5% CO2 in
a humidified incubator. The media were changed every two days. Cells were
monitored daily using phase contrast microscopy, then sub cultured when they
were confluent. The cultured endothelial cells were identified by FITC labeled
FDA (Fluorescein Diacetate, 4μgr/ml
working solution - Sigma Aldrich) using fluorescence microscopy (Nikon eclipse
80i with Nikon digital sight DS-L1). Cells grown to a 90% confluence were trypsin
zed and transferred on the biomaterial's surfaces.
4.3. Cell Seeding Procedure
Acellular BP specimen from the three groups (Triton, Trypsin/EDTA and Synovis -
Veritas) cut into 10 mm diameter discs were placed into separate wells of a
24-well plate. The fibrous layer of the matrix was facing down so that cells
would be seeded on their initial mesothelial (heart-facing in vivo) surface. The samples were
sterilized prior to endothelialization using UV lamb in the laminar flow
chamber. Afterwards, they were incubated in supplemented
DMEM medium overnight. Cultured cells were harvested from the culture
flasks using 0,05% Trypsin/EDTA solutions (Bio chrome) and re suspended in the
culture medium to a concentration of 1×104 cells/cm2. Then the pellets
of the re suspended cells were transferred and placed on the specimens’
surface. After 30 min of incubation, the culture media was completed to a total
volume 2ml per well. Seeded cells were cultured for a period up to
six days, during which the medium was changed every other day.
4.4. Characterization
of Attached Endothelial Cells
4.4.1.
Fluorescent Microscopy
After the seeding
period, changes in the cell viability and morphology due to cell material
interactions (attachment) were analyzed by indirect fluorescent staining and
fluorescent microscopy. Cell viability was detected with the use of the live
dye Fluorescein Diacetate (FDA), by which the viable cells were stained green.
DAPI - phalloidin (Sigma Aldrich) double staining was used to identify blue
stained cell nucleus and green actin filaments of endothelia attached on
acellular bovine pericardial materials. Subsequent microscopic analyses were used to confirm homogeneity
of surface cell distribution as well local surface cell density.
4.4.2.
Scanning Electron
Microscopy
The cell-seeded
pericardia were fixed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde solution for 20 min, dehydrated with
a graded series of ethanol,
and dried at 4°C overnight. The dried
samples were sputter coated with gold and the pericardial samples were examined
using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) (Zeiss Evo Ma10). The cell - cell
and cell - pericardium interactions were thus observed and analyzed.
4.5. Adhesion Assays
4.5.1.
Description of Spinning Disc Device
The details of the test apparatus have been described elsewhere [29]. In brief, it consists mainly of a cylindrical
chamber made of Plexiglas® containing
PBS buffer (pH 7.5, room temperature), and a stainless-steel shaft, ended to a
circular disc to hold the sample discs, rotated by a DC electric motor (Figure 1). Each specimen disc was glued to the holder
faced to the bottom of the chamber. The motor allowed the rotation of the disc
in the buffer under controlled rotation speeds. Four triangular plates mounted
perpendicularly at the bottom of the chamber and a collar around the rotating
disc holder prevent or minimize the rotation of the bulk liquid in the plane of
the disc and secure laminar fluid flow even at maximum rotational speeds (315
rads/sec). During rotation of the disc into the immobilized buffer solution a
shear stress field was exerted on the endothelial cells, depending on the speed
of rotation, which causes their partial detachment.
An angular velocity ω
= 230.2 rad/s was applied to the motor resulting in a
linearly increased shear stress field ranged from zero (center) to a maximum
124.37 dyn/cm2 at edge (Figure 2).
4.5.2.
Cell Detachment Experiments
After a four days’ incubation period in a 24-well plate the samples were
spun in the spinning disc device for 10 min with a rotation speed 2199 rpm
(230.2 rad/s). The hydrodynamic shear gradient applied to the cell population
caused the detachment of cells if the shear stress exceeded the total strength
of the bonds attaching the cell on the substrate. After the end of spinning testing
the disks were removed, cells’ nuclei stained (DAPI) and stepwise surface
density of the cells remained attached, in 1mm2
square frame steps, was measured across two rectangular specimen diameters by
fluorescence microscopy and averaged. Detachment of the cells, as a percentage
of local cell density divided by that of the central point (considered as 100%
due to zero local stress) was thus determined with respect of τ.
4.6. Statistical Analysis
Data were
expressed as mean values +/- standard deviation. Continuous data among groups
were compared using repeated measurement analysis of variance followed by 95%
confidence interval of the difference among studied materials (T-test).
p<0.05 was considered as significant. Analysis was performed using SPSS for
Windows, release 17.0.0 (SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL, USA).
5.
Results
5.1. Cell Attachment
and Proliferation on Scaffold
Endothelial cells
cultured on decellularized BP scaffolds were viable and showed good
proliferation as ascertained by fluorescence microscopy. Cell adhesion was
monitored as soon as 2 hours after culturing the cells on acellular BP surfaces
(Figure 3). Even at this short time a small cell
population had already adhered to the pericardium, indicating that its surface
is a suitable substrate for cell growth. Cell proliferation and growth was
monitored over periods of 24 hours to 6 days of culture. On 6th day, the
surface of the biomaterials had become coated 100% with cells. The mechanisms of cell attachment, including
structural elements such as the cell cytoskeleton and focal adhesions were examined using immune fluorescent labeling of actin
filaments
(Phalloidin) and nuclei (DAPI).
Figure 4 shows endothelial
cells lining after 4 days’ cell culture, building a confluent monolayer on the inner surface of Triton (A) and Trypsin/EDTA (B)
decellularized
BP tissues. Similar cell configuration was detected on
BP acellular matrix and on Synovis –Veritas material (C). Microscopic
analysis confirmed the homogeneous distribution of cells on bovine pericardial
tissue surface (approximately 95% confluence).The averaged local cell density
at the center and at different step distances towards the perimeter of the disk
samples of three groups was 151.6±19.2 cells/mm2
for Triton BP, significantly greater than for Trypsin BP (99.0±17.1 cells/mm2, p=0.048) and for Synovis - Veritas (91.2±31.9 cells/mm2, p=0,047) (n=5, average±stdev).
5.2. Cell Adhesion
5.2.1.
SEM Analysis of
Cell Morphology
Cell adhesion was determined by their pseudopodia
developed towards BP surface, as demonstrated in SEM
photomicrographs (Figure 5). It clearly shows the presence of BAEC developed pseudopodia attached on to
BP surface. Intercellular interactions are also showed, as multiple cells are
attached in a way to build tight cell junctions and prominent intercellular
adhesion (A1 and A2).
5.2.2.
Analysis
of Cell Adhesion Strength
As cells, cultured for four days, adhered in different positions across the
diameter of the specimen disc, they were imposed in different shear stress
levels during disk spinning, higher in longer distance from the center at a
given rotational velocity (Figure 2). After spinning
tests, cells that remained attached
were microscope examined and photographed across two vertical diameters.
Sequential microscope pictures of quadrant format 1mm2 were then
spliced and the local cell densities were measured using Sigma Scan Pro 5
software. Figure 6 shows a sequence of such
pictures across two vertical diameters, demonstrating that the highest
cell density measured at the center (τ=0),
gradually reduced towards the perimeter, at highest stress (τmax).
Supposing
no cell detachment at central region (where τ
limits to zero), the absolute
value of cell density after four days’ culture for Triton BP was significantly
greater than for Trypsin BP and for Synovis-Veritas (mean #cells/mm2 +/- SDEV, n=4).
A
reduced surface cell density, with respect to 100% at center, was computed to
assess the attachment strength of the cells to the surface of the scaffolds,
expressed as % cells remained attached after imposing in different shear strain
levels. Diagrams in figure 7 show a gradual,
near exponential, decrease in reduced cell density from 100% at central
spinning disk region to a minimum 15.53 ± 5.21%
for Triton decellularization, at disk edge region where maximum τ was applied. Trypsin/EDTA treatment exhibited a
significantly higher reduced cell density (43.10 ±
10%) (p=0.001) at edge, while the Veritas-Synovis acellular BP patches showed
almost uniform distribution without significant cell detachment after spinning
testing across the spinning disk diameter (mean ±
SDEV, n=4 for all). The rectangular frame in the diagrams of Figure 7 focused in the physiological shear stress
range (15 to 40 dyn/cm2) like
that applied at the lumen of blood vessel walls during normal blood circulation
[32]. Within that range approximately 75-55% of
the cells remained attached to Triton, 90-70% to Trypsin-EDTA and 96-93% to
Synovis-Veritas acellular BP surface (corresponding cell density at Table 1). At the higher physiological shear stress
(40dyn/cm2), all the three scaffold
materials demonstrated similar cell attachment strength (non-significant
differences were detected).
6.
Discussion
For the creation of functional
scaffold for tissue engineering that mimic the native soft tissue as closely as
possible, in
vitro studies of the interaction between cells and biomaterials need
to be addressed. This cell-biomaterial interface is strongly related to the
composition and structure of scaffold material and its ability to provide
cell-specific protein junctions for growth of appropriate ligaments. The Extra-cellular Matrix
(ECM) of decellularized animal tissues may fulfill those requirements, provided
that in vivo ECM structure and composition are preserved during
decellularization. If so, acellular ECM may retain the proteins and appropriate
biological indices, mechanical strength, resistance to enzymatic degradation
and biocompatibility that have the potential to synthesize appropriate
biochemical and biomechanical signaling to activate cell expression,
differentiation and function towards tissue regeneration after implantation [33].
Previous studies on detergent and
enzymatic treatment based decellularization of BP showed superiority of
detergent method against enzymatic decellularization regarding ECM content and
composition (especially for hyaluronan and other GAGs), as well mechanical
behavior. In that work we
successfully achieved full decellularization using detergents such as Triton,
SDS, deoxycholate [26]. Several published works reported
shortcomings of using SDS for decellularization such as difficulties in
completely removing SDS molecules from tissues, cytotoxic effects and upregulation
of elastases [34-36]. However, our preliminary
results presented in the above mentioned work didn’t show such effects.
In the present research we cultured
BAEC on alternatively decellularized BP tissues and investigated the
relationship of the resulted differences in ECM structure and mechanical
properties, as demonstrated after decellularization, with endothelial cell
attachment. After being cultured on scaffolds in static conditions, BAEC
adhered and proliferated, typically forming tight cell structures on the
scaffold surfaces (Figures 3 & 4). In that
figures a uniform cell distribution on the surface of pericardial samples was
showed with a good confluence at short time (2 hours) continued for longer time
(95% and 100% confluence in 4 and six days). Again, no restrictions were
presented due to the use of SDS for that periods (up to six days).
SEM micrographs (Figure 5) showed that binding between cell actin
filaments and substrate surface was more evident in the case of Triton,
compared with Trypsin/EDTA treated BP. This was quantitatively verified by the
results of the shear stress application to the adhered cells by the spinning
disc test. The spinning disc device was adopted to be used in combination with
fluorescence microscopy, which allowed imaging, analyzing and counting of
fluorescently stained cells on biomaterials before and after the application of
appropriate shear stress field on their surfaces. This methodology enables an
improved quantification of the adhesion strength since surface cell density
before and after rotation at a given position can be accurately measured. Fine cell
spreading and proliferation on biomaterials’ surface and good surface cell
density was measured after 4 days’ cultivation at the central disk region,
where shear stress is minimal. The results in table 1 showed
that absolute cell density demonstrated the superiority of Triton treatment
against the Trypsin/EDTA, as measured at regions of minimal stress.
Cell density was
decreased across the disk diameter with increasing the distance from the
central point, hence increasing shear stress (Figures 2
and 6). The expression of cell counts by the reduced cell density
presented here (Figure 7) is suitable for a
direct objective comparison of the cell adhesion strength on the surface of
different biomaterials under similar stress fields. The results showed a normal
dependence of the reduced cell density to the shear strength for Triton-treated
BP, an abnormal dependence for Trypsin/EDTA and practical no stress dependence
for Trypsin based treatment for the Synovis-Verittas biomaterials. A direct
comparison of absolute cell density, supposing uniform initial cell
distribution over the surface of the disks seems to decrease the differences at
maximum shear strength 120 dyn/cm2,
however even in that case the results showed a decreased resistant of the cells
adhered on Triton treated BP, a medium resistance for Trypsin/EDTA and a great
resistance for the Synovis-Verittas material.
This is evident
that cells were adhered on the surface of ECM with different strength. This
must have attributed to many reasons, like the surface chemistry of
biomaterials, micro-Nano topography, cell population etc. The number of cells
attached per surface area play an important role; if cell density increases,
the possibility for the number of binding linkages of cell cytoskeleton
directly to biomaterial surface is decreased, as some cells may adhere to other
cells via intercellular binding linkages, as evident in Figures 5A1 & 5A2 [37,38]. It seems from the results that the
higher cell density of Triton-treated BP contributed to the weaker cell
attachment on the surface. Surface chemistry and micro-Nano topography were not
studied, as it was beyond the scope of this work.
Looking however at
the physiological stress range applied to endothelial cell during normal blood
circulation (rectangular frames in the diagrams of Figure
7) it seems that such differences were minimized. Even at the higher
physiological shear stress of 40 dyn/cm2
a satisfactory percentage of cell remain attached to all the three biomaterial
surfaces. Investigation towards the perfect scaffold for cardiovascular tissue
engineering remains an enormous challenge. It is now unambiguous that
cardiovascular scaffolds should fulfill several well-defined requisites:
mechanical strength to withstand pressure in body, elasticity to provide
compliance and recoil, cellular compatibility, ability to be repopulated and
remodeled by host cells, lack of thrombogenicity and immunogenicity of the
scaffold material and a confluent, shear resistant endothelium to resist
thrombosis. An overall comparison regarding biochemical structure and content,
biomechanical behavior [26] and capability for
cell attachment between the biomaterials examined demonstrated the superiority
of Triton against Trypsin based treatment for the creation of decellularized
animal derived scaffolds.
In conclusion, successfully re-endothelialized
acellular naturally derived biomaterial revealed cell-adhesion properties on
biomaterial’s surface, which are likely to be favorable to improve neo-tissue
regenerative performance of biomaterials. Further research is in progress on
undifferentiated mesenchymal stem cells seeded and cultured in bioreactor.
Figure
1: Photograph of the spinning disk device, used to produce a shear stress
field induced on the endothelial cells cultured
on acellular bovine pericardial biomaterial, by rotating the disks into an
immobilized buffer solution.
Figure 2: Diagram of the
shear stress field developed across the disk diameter (zero
at center to a maximum at the periphery of the disc).
Figure 3: Characteristic image of fluorescence microscopy determining adhesion
of bovine aortic endothelial cells on
decellularized BP
surface, after double staining
with phalloidin - DAPI. Nuclei in blue and actin
in in green, magnification 20x.
Figure
4: Representative images showing bovine aortic endothelial cell growth on the surface of
acellular bovine pericardial tissue after 4 days of culture. A - Triton
decellularization, B -Trypsin decellularization C - Synovis Veritas. Staining
for live cells, FDA. Magnification 20x.
Figure 5: SEM photomicrographs of bovine aortic endothelial cells (BAEC)
cultured on acellular pericardial
tissues treated with Triton X-100/SDS (A 1-3) and Trypsin/EDTA solution
(B 1-3), for 4 days. The presence
of developed pseudopodia (arrows) attached on to BP surface is clearly
indicated.